Quilters Select Mat vs Olfa Mat — Which Self-Healing Cutting Mat Is Better?

Quilters Select Self-Healing Mat vs Olfa Mat — Which Is Better?

Cutting mats look similar but perform very differently over time. Quilters Select and Olfa are two of the top brands — here’s an honest comparison of their self-healing mats to help you choose.

Linda’s Electric Quilters Expert Comparison

Head-to-Head Comparison

Feature Quilters Select Mat Olfa Mat
Self-healing quality Excellent QS Excellent Olfa
Grid accuracy Laser-etched, very accurate QS Printed grid, accurate
Blade friendliness Extends blade life QS Good blade life
Double-sided Yes Tie Yes
Smell Minimal QS Some chemical smell when new
Warp resistance Good — avoid direct sun Tie Good — avoid direct sun
Price Slightly higher Slightly lower Olfa
Sizes available Standard quilting sizes Very wide range Olfa
▶ Our VerdictBoth are excellent self-healing mats. Quilters Select has the edge on grid accuracy and blade longevity. Olfa has the edge on size range and price. For most quilters, either will serve you well for 5–10 years. The differences are subtle — choose based on which brand’s other tools you already use.

Cutting Mat Care Tips

To maximize mat life

  • Rotate the mat regularly to distribute wear evenly
  • Use both sides to double usable surface
  • Store flat — never roll or fold
  • Keep away from heat, sunlight, and radiators
  • Clean with mild soap and water periodically

Signs it’s time to replace

  • Deep grooves that catch and deflect the blade
  • Warping that won’t flatten under a quilt ruler
  • Grid lines that are no longer accurate
  • Surface stops healing cuts (stays open)

Frequently Asked Questions

Can I use any rotary cutter on any cutting mat?

Yes — cutting mats are not brand-specific. Any 45mm or 60mm rotary cutter will work with any quality self-healing mat. The mat surface softens the blade impact; a quality mat extends blade life regardless of cutter brand.

Why does my cutting mat smell?

New cutting mats have a characteristic chemical smell from the PVC or polymer compounds used in manufacturing. The smell dissipates within a few days of use and airing out. If the smell persists, try cleaning the mat with a mild soapy water solution and rinsing thoroughly.

What size cutting mat should I buy?

18"×24" is the recommended starting size for most quilters — it fits on a standard table and handles most strip cutting. If you have a dedicated quilting cutting station, upgrade to 24"×36".

Shop Cutting Mats at Linda’s Electric Quilters

Expert longarm advice • Trusted since 1999

Shop All Cutting Mats